Best Cookie Bakeries in Brooklyn, NY
Doughful features hand-picked cookie bakeries in Brooklyn, NY — vetted for quality, creativity, and flavor. Each listing includes verified Google reviews, current hours, directions, and direct links to order online.
Filter:
All
Ships Nationwide
Local Only
Vegan Options
Showing 9 cookie bakeries
Top Rated
Name A–Z
Ships Nationwide First
📍 Brooklyn, NY · Ships nationwide
★★★★★
4.7
(3201 reviews)
“The Compost Cookie is pure genius — pretzels, potato chips, coffee grounds and chocolate all in one cookie. Christina Tosi is a baking le...”
📍 Brooklyn, NY · Ships nationwide
★★★★★
4.7
(2910 reviews)
“The Brooklyn Blackout cookie brownie hybrid is one of the most decadent things I've ever consumed. Their Oprah-approved brownies are next...”
★★★★★
4.7
(1680 reviews)
“Scandinavian pastry perfection in Brooklyn. The kouign-amann is deeply caramelized and crispy, the Danish are genuinely stunning.”
📍 Brooklyn, NY · Ships nationwide
★★★★★
4.7
(2340 reviews)
“The most refined croissant in New York — deeply caramelized, shattering layers, and extraordinary flavor. Worth every penny.”
★★★★★
4.6
(1890 reviews)
“Parisian-style pastries in Brooklyn. The almond croissant is world-famous but their sablé cookies with chocolate ganache are quietly bril...”
★★★★★
4.6
(1540 reviews)
“The Brown Butter Chocolate Chip cookie here is revelatory. Full bar plus incredible baked goods — the ultimate Brooklyn combination.”
📍 Brooklyn, NY · Ships nationwide
★★★★★
4.6
(2140 reviews)
“The salty chocolate chip cookie is the definitive version of the form — perfectly calibrated salt, dark chocolate, and chewy edges. A mas...”
📍 Brooklyn, NY · Ships nationwide
★★★★★
4.4
(15700 reviews)
“Late-night cookies delivered warm to your door — what more could you want? The double chocolate chunk is incredible at midnight.”
