Doughful Directory

Best Cake Bakeries
in Brooklyn, NY

Hand-picked cake bakeries vetted for quality, creativity, and flavor.

10Bakeries
—Ship Nationally
—Vegan Options
Doughful › Cake Bakeries › Brooklyn, NY › Cake Bakeries in Brooklyn

Best Cake Bakeries in Brooklyn, NY

Doughful features hand-picked cake bakeries in Brooklyn, NY — vetted for quality, creativity, and flavor. Each listing includes verified Google reviews, current hours, directions, and direct links to order online.

Filter:

Showing 10 cake bakeries

Beard_Papa_Variety_of_Pastry_Puffs
Beard Papa's
📍 Brooklyn, NY
★★★★★ 4.8 (243 reviews)
“Neat place 👌🏼. It has a row of claw machines along the front window inside the place to keep you entertained while waiting for your puffs...”
Shop Now →📍 Directions
Milk Bar photo 3
Milk Bar
📍 Brooklyn, NY · Ships nationwide
★★★★★ 4.7 (3201 reviews)
“The Compost Cookie is pure genius — pretzels, potato chips, coffee grounds and chocolate all in one cookie. Christina Tosi is a baking le...”
Shop Now →📍 Directions
Baked NYC photo 1
Baked NYC
📍 Brooklyn, NY · Ships nationwide
★★★★★ 4.7 (2910 reviews)
“The Brooklyn Blackout cookie brownie hybrid is one of the most decadent things I've ever consumed. Their Oprah-approved brownies are next...”
Shop Now →📍 Directions
Colson Patisserie photo 1
Colson Patisserie
📍 Brooklyn, NY
★★★★★ 4.7 (1680 reviews)
“Scandinavian pastry perfection in Brooklyn. The kouign-amann is deeply caramelized and crispy, the Danish are genuinely stunning.”
Shop Now →📍 Directions
Bien Cuit photo 3
Bien Cuit
📍 Brooklyn, NY · Ships nationwide
★★★★★ 4.7 (2340 reviews)
“The most refined croissant in New York — deeply caramelized, shattering layers, and extraordinary flavor. Worth every penny.”
Shop Now →📍 Directions
Butter & Scotch photo 1
Butter & Scotch
📍 Brooklyn, NY
★★★★★ 4.6 (1540 reviews)
“The Brown Butter Chocolate Chip cookie here is revelatory. Full bar plus incredible baked goods — the ultimate Brooklyn combination.”
Shop Now →📍 Directions
OV
Ovenly
📍 Brooklyn, NY · Ships nationwide
★★★★★ 4.6 (2140 reviews)
“The salty chocolate chip cookie is the definitive version of the form — perfectly calibrated salt, dark chocolate, and chewy edges. A mas...”
Shop Now →📍 Directions
SM
Sweet Melissa Patisserie
📍 Brooklyn, NY
★★★★★ 4.6 (1890 reviews)
“Parisian-style pastries in Brooklyn. The almond croissant is world-famous but their sablé cookies with chocolate ganache are quietly bril...”
Shop Now →📍 Directions
Tous_Les_Jours_Pastries
TOUS les JOURS Aurora
📍 Brooklyn, NY
★★★★★ 4.5 (700 reviews)
“I did takeout and as I purchased one to have amd share. A blueberry cheese danish and one grape & berries pastry. Both had a great flavo...”
Shop Now →📍 Directions
Insomnia_Cookies_Red_Velvet_Cream_Filled_Cookies
Insomnia Cookies
📍 Brooklyn, NY · Ships nationwide
★★★★★ 4.4 (15700 reviews)
“Late-night cookies delivered warm to your door — what more could you want? The double chocolate chunk is incredible at midnight.”
Shop Now →📍 Directions

More in Brooklyn

More Cake Bakeries Cities

Cake Bakeries in Albuquerque, NMCake Bakeries in Ann Arbor, MICake Bakeries in Arlington, TXCake Bakeries in Athens, GACake Bakeries in Atlanta, GACake Bakeries in Austin, TXCake Bakeries in Baltimore, MDCake Bakeries in Baton Rouge, LACake Bakeries in Birmingham, ALCake Bakeries in Boise, IDCake Bakeries in Boston, MACake Bakeries in Buford, GACake Bakeries in Cambridge, MACake Bakeries in Charlotte, NCCake Bakeries in Chattanooga, TNCake Bakeries in Chicago, ILCake Bakeries in Colorado Springs, COCake Bakeries in Columbia, MDCake Bakeries in Columbia, MOCake Bakeries in Columbia, SCCake Bakeries in Columbus, OHCake Bakeries in Dallas, TXCake Bakeries in Denver, COCake Bakeries in El Paso, TXCake Bakeries in Fayetteville, ARCake Bakeries in Flushing, NYCake Bakeries in Fort Myers, FLCake Bakeries in Fort Worth, TXCake Bakeries in Franklin, TNCake Bakeries in Frisco, TXCake Bakeries in Grand Rapids, MICake Bakeries in Greenville, SCCake Bakeries in Henderson, NVCake Bakeries in Houston, TXCake Bakeries in Indianapolis, INCake Bakeries in Jacksonville, FLCake Bakeries in Katy, TXCake Bakeries in Knoxville, TNCake Bakeries in Las Vegas, NVCake Bakeries in Los Angeles, CACake Bakeries in Louisville, KYCake Bakeries in Lubbock, TXCake Bakeries in Madison, WICake Bakeries in Memphis, TNCake Bakeries in Mesquite, TXCake Bakeries in Miami, FLCake Bakeries in Minneapolis, MNCake Bakeries in Naperville, ILCake Bakeries in Nashville, TNCake Bakeries in New Orleans, LACake Bakeries in New York, NYCake Bakeries in Oklahoma City, OKCake Bakeries in Orlando, FLCake Bakeries in Overland Park, KSCake Bakeries in Paramus, NJCake Bakeries in Pembroke Pines, FLCake Bakeries in Philadelphia, PACake Bakeries in Pittsburgh, PACake Bakeries in Portland, ORCake Bakeries in Raleigh, NCCake Bakeries in Richardson, TXCake Bakeries in Richmond, VACake Bakeries in Sacramento, CACake Bakeries in Salt Lake City, UTCake Bakeries in San Antonio, TXCake Bakeries in San Diego, CACake Bakeries in San Francisco, CACake Bakeries in San Jose, CACake Bakeries in Schaumburg, ILCake Bakeries in Scottsdale, AZCake Bakeries in Seattle, WACake Bakeries in Spokane, WACake Bakeries in Spring, TXCake Bakeries in St. Louis, MOCake Bakeries in Sugar Land, TXCake Bakeries in Tampa, FLCake Bakeries in Tucson, AZCake Bakeries in Washington, DC