Best Cookie Bakeries in Indianapolis, IN
Doughful features hand-picked cookie bakeries in Indianapolis, IN — vetted for quality, creativity, and flavor. Each listing includes verified Google reviews, current hours, directions, and direct links to order online.
Filter:
All
Ships Nationwide
Local Only
Vegan Options
Showing 7 cookie bakeries
Top Rated
Name A–Z
Ships Nationwide First
★★★★★
4.9
(423 reviews)
“When I moved to Indy a little over a year ago, I was excited to try Rene's and never quite found a time in my schedule to visit before th...”
★★★★★
4.6
(116 reviews)
“My husband and I visited here for the first time today. We were in the area shopping and going out for lunch.
We bought 2 cupcakes - one ...”
📍 Indianapolis, IN · Ships nationwide
★★★★★
4.5
(28401 reviews)
“The rotating weekly menu keeps things exciting. The pink sugar cookie with almond frosting is absolutely divine and they're massive!”
📍 Indianapolis, IN · Ships nationwide
★★★★★
4.5
(2340 reviews)
“Franchise with heart — the cookies are always fresh and the rotating specials keep you coming back. Red Velvet cookie is superb.”
★★★★★
4.5
(186 reviews)
“I went to Crave to buy 2 cookies each for my co-workers. More than 2 and they would curse me for the calories! I *could not* make up my...”
★★★★★
4.4
(12000 reviews)
📍 Indianapolis, IN · Ships nationwide
★★★★★
4.4
(15700 reviews)
“Late-night cookies delivered warm to your door — what more could you want? The double chocolate chunk is incredible at midnight.”
