Best Cookie Bakeries in New York, NY
Doughful features hand-picked cookie bakeries in New York, NY — vetted for quality, creativity, and flavor. Each listing includes verified Google reviews, current hours, directions, and direct links to order online.
Filter:
All
Ships Nationwide
Local Only
Vegan Options
Showing 12 cookie bakeries
Top Rated
Name A–Z
Ships Nationwide First
📍 New York, NY · Ships nationwide
★★★★★
4.9
(4812 reviews)
“Absolutely life-changing cookies. The chocolate chip walnut is thick, crispy on the outside and perfectly gooey inside. Worth every penny.”
📍 New York, NY · Ships nationwide
★★★★★
4.8
(7840 reviews)
“Home of the Cronut and so much more. The chocolate chip cookie shots — warm cookie cups filled with cold milk — are a genuinely genius in...”
★★★★★
4.8
(1211 reviews)
“I had a great experience with Buttercup BakeShop and would highly recommend them to others!
We had Buttercup BakeShop make a custom cake...”
📍 New York, NY · Ships nationwide
★★★★★
4.7
(4870 reviews)
“Thomas Keller's TKO cookie — the dark chocolate sablé sandwich with Oreo-style cream — is the most refined version of a classic you'll ev...”
📍 New York, NY · Ships nationwide
★★★★★
4.7
(2840 reviews)
“The coziest cookie experience in New York. The classic chocolate chip and the ice cream sandwiches are the stuff of West Village dreams.”
★★★★★
4.7
(312 reviews)
“I recently celebrated my birthday and had the pleasure of ordering my cake from “Que Lo Cake”aka Huascar & Co. Bakeshop.
From the moment ...”
📍 New York, NY · Ships nationwide
★★★★★
4.7
(3201 reviews)
“The Compost Cookie is pure genius — pretzels, potato chips, coffee grounds and chocolate all in one cookie. Christina Tosi is a baking le...”
📍 New York, NY · Ships nationwide
★★★★★
4.7
(2872 reviews)
“The mille crêpe cake is legendary but the petit fours and tea cookies elevate what a bakery cookie can be. Pure elegance in every bite.”
📍 New York, NY · Ships nationwide
★★★★★
4.7
(2100 reviews)
“The most refined chocolate experience in New York. The handmade chocolate mouse truffles are iconic but the chocolate shortbread cookies ...”
📍 New York, NY · Ships nationwide
★★★★★
4.6
(12400 reviews)
“Made famous by the TLC show but earns every bit of the hype. The lemon blossom and red velvet cupcakes are genuinely outstanding.”
📍 New York, NY · Ships nationwide
★★★★★
4.6
(742 reviews)
“These S'mores cookies have ruined every other cookie for me. Gooey, warm, and dangerously addictive. Order the warm ones!”
📍 New York, NY · Ships nationwide
★★★★★
4.6
(1870 reviews)
“French macarons done to absolute perfection — dozens of flavors, always fresh. The salted caramel and pistachio are transcendent.”
