Gooey on the Inside
New York's gooey stuffed cookie specialists, baked to order.
Gooey on the Inside is a cookies, brownies bakery in New York, NY, shipping nationwide.
⭐ 4.6 — 742 reviews
Specializing in: Cookies, Brownies
Gooey on the Inside Locations
- New York, NY 10001, New York, NY
Hours
- Monday:Closed
- Tuesday:Closed
- Wednesday:Closed
- Thursday:Closed
- Friday:2:00 PM – 1:00 AM
- Saturday:12:00 PM – 1:00 AM
- Sunday:12:00 – 10:00 PM
What Customers Say About Gooey on the Inside
“I popped into this unique little dessert spot on Chrystie Street for a late-afternoon sweet treat, and it was definitely memorable. The vibe is cozy and a bit tucked-away — you’ll find it down below street level in a small space that feels more like a local find than a typical bakery. What they’re known for are their thick, gooey cookies — served warm with a soft, almost molten center and a…” — Tctgb1, 5/5 stars
“Naaaaaah, this ain’t it yall. For one this cookie is ridiculously too sweet. Two, It hard to even call it a cookie, it’s not flat, rather oblate, it might as well be sphere. Lastly, I’m all for a cookie with a gooey center but c’mon it’s not even cooked at this point it’s just a ball of cookie dough. Smh I really wanted to like it but if I’d make any suggestion it would be make them flatter, semi…” — Wallace Kolour, 2/5 stars
“This hole in the wall (literally located in a basement!) cookie shop is so underrated !! The name of the shop is very fitting for its menu items, as all the cookies had a harder outer shell and the gooeist / slightly underbaked insides🙂↕️🙂↕️All of the cookies came out super warm, and when you break it apart all the chocolate is half-melted 🍫This place also has some creative items, like the…” — Hailey Kim, 5/5 stars
“I’ve walked past this spot so many times and was always a little skeptical, but I finally gave it a try — and I’m so glad I did. This place deserves way more attention. The chocolate chip cookie tasted homemade, not overly sweet like most popular cookie spots in the city. I usually can only take a few bites and end up sharing because it’s too much, but with this one, I didn’t want to stop eating.…” — P L, 5/5 stars
“The people working behind the counter were incredibly friendly and warm. The cookies are $8 each but they are huge, and can easily be split between friends. I loved the apple pie cookie, not too sweet and it tasted just like apple pie crust. The banana cream pie filling was a little too sweet for me but the cookie itself tasted like nilla wafers and was so yummy.” — Jess Nogan, 5/5 stars
Loading bakery...