A Piece of Cake
Custom cakes & a rotating array of pies & seasonal desserts are made at this family-owned mainstay.
A Piece of Cake is a cakes bakery in Indianapolis, IN.
⭐ 4.7 — 173 reviews
Specializing in: Cakes
A Piece of Cake Locations
- 484 N Madison Ave, Greenwood, Indianapolis, IN — (317) 887-2253
Hours
- Monday:10:00 AM – 6:00 PM
- Tuesday:Closed
- Wednesday:10:00 AM – 4:00 PM
- Thursday:10:00 AM – 4:00 PM
- Friday:10:00 AM – 6:00 PM
- Saturday:9:00 AM – 2:00 PM
- Sunday:Closed
What Customers Say About A Piece of Cake
“A Piece of Cake always comes through with AMAZING cakes for my daughter's birthdays! They are beautifully decorated, and most importantly, delicious! You can tell a huge difference between their cake and something you'd get at the store. They're easy to communicate with via phone or email, and upfront about pricing. They also give a set of free plates, napkins and forks which is an unexpected…” — Jessie Grimston, 5/5 stars
“I ordered a custom cake from this bakery, and it turned out absolutely amazing! 🎂 The cake was soft, fresh, and so delicious, everyone loved it. What really impressed me was the customer service. I had requested the cake earlier than planned, and she kindly made it ready ahead of time without any hesitation. She was super friendly and helpful throughout the process. I’ll definitely be coming…” — Karamjeet Kaur, 5/5 stars
“I’ve ordered many cakes from here, and the photos attached are just a few that I remembered to take! Every cake turns out amazing, beautifully decorated, super delicious, and always ready on time for pickup. I provide pictures of the cakes I want and it always comes out exactly like the pictures. Their prices are very reasonable, and the customer service is wonderful. The shop itself is also…” — Mon Htaw, 5/5 stars
“We LOVE A Piece of Cake for our birthday cakes. They nailed this Frozen themed cake which was beautiful and delicious! They even accommodated us when we called the day before to request a larger size. Thank you!” — Tessa Miller, 5/5 stars
“Thank you A Piece of Cake for our beautiful vintage wedding cake. It was exactly what we wanted & tasted AMAZING. I highly recommend this shop for delicious tasting cake for any occasion!” — Kaitlyn Mitchell, 5/5 stars
Loading bakery...